Why Mediate Before Trial? The Business Case for Settling Smart
Anyone who has been through a civil lawsuit knows the pattern: pleadings, productions, examinations, motions, then a trial date months or years away. Costs build at every step. Mediation interrupts that pattern.
You decide the outcome. At trial a judge decides, and either side may be disappointed. At mediation, you only agree to what you are willing to live with. That control is often the main reason people choose it.
It is confidential. What is said in mediation is generally protected. That lets parties explore options candidly without worrying it will be used against them later. That is difficult to do in a courtroom.
It can preserve relationships. Business partners, contractors, landlords and tenants, and neighbours often need to keep dealing with each other. A negotiated agreement can fix terms going forward. A judgment usually cannot.
Timing matters. Mediation is useful at any stage. Early on, it can avoid most of the expense. After documents and examinations, each side usually has a clearer picture of strengths and risks, which helps a deal. Even on the eve of trial, it is worth trying.
Ontario context. In some Ontario courts, mediation is part of the process in civil matters, so many parties will attend one at some point. Using a mediator you have chosen, when it suits you, often works better than a step ticked off to satisfy a schedule.
What I do. I stay neutral. I do not advise either side on their case. I help each party prepare, keep the conversation productive, and, when it helps, carry proposals between rooms. If you reach agreement, it can be put in writing before everyone leaves.
If a dispute is heading toward the courthouse, a conversation about mediation first costs very little.



Comments