top of page

Mediating an Injury Claim: What Actually Happens

Oct 29
4 min read

Most personal injury claims in Ontario settle before trial, and mediation is where many of them do. If you have never been to one, here is what to expect.


Is mediation mandatory?


In some places it is. Under Ontario's Rule 24.1, mediation is required in most civil actions, including injury claims, in Toronto, Ottawa and Windsor. Elsewhere in Ontario it is voluntary.


Where it is not required, parties still choose it often, for good reasons. It is usually faster than waiting for a trial date. It is confidential, so people can talk candidly. It costs far less than a trial. And the parties keep control: nothing is binding unless both sides agree.


What a personal injury mediation really looks like


People often picture one long conversation across a table. In practice, most injury mediations are closer to a facilitated negotiation.


The day usually begins in a joint session. I explain what mediation is, how the day will work, and that it is confidential and voluntary. Each lawyer then gives an opening statement. After that, the parties are given the chance to add their own words.


Then the group usually separates into private rooms. Much of the day is shuttle mediation: I move between the rooms, carrying offers and responses, and talking through each side's thinking in private.


Where a neutral mediator adds value


Carrying numbers back and forth is the visible part. The skill is in what happens around it:


  • Asking good questions so each side tests its own assumptions, without me telling anyone what their case is worth.


  • Making sure each side understands the other's position, including the reasons behind it.


  • Managing emotion and pace, so a hard moment doesn't end the day early.


  • Keeping the conversation moving when talks stall, and helping parties see options they hadn't considered, such as payment structure or timing.


  • Staying neutral throughout. I don't advocate for either side or push a result. Lawyers advise their clients on value and risk. My job is to help the negotiation work.


Who talks during an injury mediation?


Typically it goes in this order. The mediator speaks first, explaining the process. Each lawyer gives an opening statement. The mediator then invites the parties to speak if they wish.


Should the injured person speak? In most cases, I think yes.


Before the mediation, the person responding for the defence, who decides whether and how to settle, usually knows the injured person only as a statement of claim and a stack of medical records. The defence lawyer may have met them at an examination for discovery, but the decision-maker usually has not. A mediation is often the only time that person hears directly from the injured person.


A few words from the injured person can change how a file is seen. It gives the other party a human connection that paper cannot. It can work the other way too: hearing from the decision-maker helps the injured person understand the other side's position.


That said, speaking is not always appropriate. It may not be advisable where there are medical, psychological, emotional barriers or other reasons that may make it difficult for the injured person to speak in an open forum. That is a judgment call for the injured person and their lawyer, and I'm comfortable either way. My role is to make sure whoever does speak is heard respectfully.


Preparing for the day


Preparation makes a real difference. It shapes how the day goes and how confident people feel making decisions.


If you are the injured person


  • Review your own medical records. Know what they say about your injuries, treatment and prognosis, and be ready to ask your lawyer about anything unclear.


  • Read your own mediation brief and the other party. Each side usually prepares a short document setting out its position. Knowing how the other party sees the claim helps you avoid surprises.


  • Meet your lawyer beforehand. Talk through what a good resolution looks like for you, including what matters beyond the dollar figure. Ask for their view of the risks and the range they consider realistic.


  • Decide whether you will speak, and what you might say. Discuss this as part of your preparation. If you do speak, think about how your injuries have changed your daily life, work and plans. You do not need a script. A few honest, simple words are usually enough.


If you represent the defendant


  • Review the claim materials, the medical records, and both mediation briefs.


  • Make sure the person with settlement authority attends, or can be reached.


  • Think about how you would respond if the injured person addresses you directly. Respectful listening goes a long way, regardless of how the file is valued.


For everyone


Come ready to listen as well as to negotiate. Expect the day to take time, and expect offers to move in steps. Reaching a settlement usually means giving up something you wanted, and the parties who come prepared are better able to decide when a deal is good enough.


If you would like to know more about how mediation might work in your claim, I'm happy to talk it through.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page